1972 - Jim Kruzich - E (first team)
1979 - Terry Geraghty - DB (first team)
1994 - Matt Malmberg - RB (first team), Chris Palmer - WR (first team), Brian Kohorst - DL (second team), Warren Bostrom - DT (second team), Jeremy Loretz - WR (second team)
1995 - Chris Palmer - WR (first team^), DJ Kor - RB (second team)
1996 - Ted Ruzanic - LB (second team)
1997 - Matt Emmerich - DB (first team)
1998 - Eric Serbus - DE (second team)
1999 - Eric Serbus - DE (second team)
2000 - Tom Linnemann - QB (second team)
2004 - Matt Hawn - LB (second team)
2005 - Matt Hawn - LB (first team), Jason Good - DL (first team)
2006 - Jamie Steffensmeier - LB (first team)
2007 - Kevin Boegel - DB (first team)
2008 - Jeff Schnobrich - RB (second team)
2009 - Nick Gunderson - DL (second team)
2010 - Jeff Gilbertson - OL (second team)
2013 - Kevin Battis - OL (second team)
2015 - Carter Hanson - LB (first team), Nick Simon - TE (first team)
2016 - Lucas Glomb - DB (first team), Carter Hanson - LB (first team), Jack Pietruszewski - DL (first team)
2017 - David Franta - LB (first team)
2018 - Will Gillach - WR (first team)
2020-21 - Tyler Johnson - OL (second team)
2021 - Tyler Johnson - OL (first team), Henry Trost - RB (second team), Michael Wozniak - DL (first team)
2022 - Michael Wozniak - DL (second team)
2024 - Zach Frank - DL (second team), Aaron Syverson - QB (first team*), Dylan Wheeler - WR (second team)
2025 - Zach Frank - DL (first team), Joey Gendreau - TE (first team), Dylan Wheeler - WR (first team)
^GTE Academic All-American of the Year
*CSC Division III Team Member of the Year
